14-05-2020
Autobiografia de 
Edith Hahn Beer
A mulher do oficial nazi
| NOTA DE LEITURA 
		
		Este livro é uma espécie de conto de fadas, tantas as peripécias por que 
		passou Edith Hahn durante a guerra. Destaca-se o seu carácter duro e 
		destemido que a tornava sempre pronta para encontrar uma saída nas 
		muitas dificuldades por que passou. .  
		
		O livro está bem escrito, mas saltam à vista as mazelas da tradução para 
		português.  
		
		Vê-se que a autora tinha um carácter forte e decidido. A história tem um 
		ponto negro evidente: quando a autora abandona a criança chamada Gretl 
		que tinha trazido para casa a fim de fazer companhia à filha. 
		Abandonou-a depois de ter convivido com ela muitos meses ou mesmo anos.  
		
		Anoto outro livro sobre a vida dela, bastante fraquinho e mais curto. O 
		título é 
		The Jewish Wife of a Nazi Officer,
		
		
		de
		
		 
		 | 
A Family Affair: Sleeping with the enemy - a survivor's tale; In 1943,
 
Edith Hahn Beer, an Austrian Jew using an assumed Aryan identity,married Werner 
Vetter, a German Nazi. They had a daughter, Angela, believed to be the only Jew 
born in a Reich hospital. Edith, 86, reclaimed her name after the war and 
divorced Werner. She now lives in Israel (died March 17, 2009). Angela Schluter, 
55, a divorced mother-of-three and an artist, lives in London. 
|  | |
March, 6, 2000
Edith Hahn Beer
I was 24 and had just finished my law degree when my mother and I were sent to 
the ghetto in Vienna. It was just after Kristallnacht. My father had died from a 
heart attack, and my two sisters had already fled to Israel. In May 1941, I was 
sent to a labour camp in the north of Germany, and then to a paper factory. When 
I returned, just over a year later, my mother had been deported to Poland. I'd 
missed her by two weeks, and never heard from her again.
I was also on the deportation list so went into hiding for six weeks. A friend then rang a man who agreed to help me. When I arrived my heart contracted - he was wearing a Nazi uniform. There was no turning back. He advised me to ask a good Aryan friend of the same age and colouring as me to report her papers missing, apply for replacements, and give me the originals. He was my saviour. He didn't ask for money;I think he did it because of our mutual friend.
In August 1942, I travelled to Munich with my friend's identity papers, and 
worked as a seamstress in return for lodgings. That month I went to an art 
gallery. I was sitting in front of a painting when a blond man with a swastika 
pin in his lapel sat down beside me and started talking to me about art. His 
name was Werner Vetter. He was very nice. He had seven days left of his holiday 
and we saw each other every day.
In October, he came back and told me he loved me and proposed marriage. It was 
horrible, I was terribly embarrassed and didn't know what to say. I gave him all 
kinds of platitudes to try and get rid of him. He said he wanted to meet the 
father I had talked about, so I told him the truth. It was a risk, but I trusted 
him because I couldsee that he loved me. He then admitted that he was married, 
and was going through a divorce. He said that we were now even because we had 
both lied. He didn't mind that I was Jewish. I think I did love him. I didn't 
consider all Nazis to be the same.
That December, I joined Werner in Brandenburg, outside Berlin, where he worked 
in an aeroplane factory. I forced myself to forget everything that was dear to 
me, all my experience of life, my education, and became a bland, prosaic, polite 
person who never said or did anything to arouse attention. We never talked about 
the Jews orwhat might be happening to my mother. I avoided shops where I would 
have to give the Heil Hitler salute, and refused to hang his picture in the 
house. But I worked for the Red Cross in a hospital, and had to wear a brooch 
which bore a swastika. I wanted a baby and got pregnant. Werner insisted that we 
married. I later gave birth to Angela, not daring to take any medication in case 
I revealed my identity.
In March 1945, Werner was sent to a Russian labour camp in Siberia. When the war 
ended, I took my Jewish identity card, which my old boyfriend had concealed in 
the covers of a book, and I got a court order for my name to be changed.
In the summer of 1947, Werner returned. By that time I was working asa judge, 
and I was Edith again. He didn't like the real me. He wanted someone to stay at 
home and look after the house. After a few months he said he wanted a divorce. I 
was distraught, but had to agree.
The Russians wanted me to work for the secret service, so I fled to England with 
Angela, then four, and became a housemaid. I didn't tell her about my past 
because I wanted her to grow up as a normal girl, and not have to live in the 
shadow of this horrible holocaust.
I see Werner as the person who saved me. I don't know whether he is still alive. 
I have no regrets. Should I regret that I wasn't burnt to death, or gassed in a 
chamber? It was a miracle.
Angela Schluter
I FOUND out that my father was a Nazi when I was 16. My mother had come up with 
the bright idea that I should get to know him. The last time I had seen him was 
when I was 11. So I went to live with him for six months in Germany. He told me 
that he had been a member of the Nazi Party. I was shocked. I couldn't cope. I 
said I didn't want to know. It was denial.
I didn't see my original birth certificate until I was 29. There was a big 
swastika stamped on it. I couldn't deny that and it really shocked me.
We didn't talk about my mother's past for many, many years. I always knew, even 
as a child, that there was something very painful and very bad about her family, 
and I wasn't to ask. Every year when I was little she would send me six birthday 
cards from people who had been killed in the Holocaust, including her mother, to 
give me the illusion of some sort of family.
In 1984 my stepfather, Fred Beer, whom my mother had married in 1957,died; she 
moved to Israel four years later. Once, when I visited her, she showed me a load 
of papers and letters from the war. I was worried that if something happened to 
her someone would go through her flat and throw them out. I brought them back to 
Germany with me and put them in a safe. I had a friend whose husband asked to 
see them. On my mother's next visit, he started asking her questions. That was 
the first time I heard her story. I was stunned. I find it amazing that anyone 
could have lived through so much terror.
I don't like my father at all. I think he's terrible. When I went to live with 
him at 16 I told him I didn't want to go to Christian religious classes at 
school (I went to a Jewish school in London). He
just looked at me and hit 
me. I still can't open my mouth properly. In the Holocaust Museum in Washington 
I saw a slide of his Nazi Party card. I felt physically sick, and the hairs 
on the back of my neck stood up. The last time I saw him was about 20 years ago.
The fact that my father was a Nazi is something I can only come to terms with in 
denial. If I was to sit and think about it I couldn't sleep at night. I still 
cannot see that Spielberg film. I'm not ashamed of what my mother did because it 
was a question of survival.I'm pleased he looked after her, and loved her, but I 
don't want anything to do with him.
Over the last six, seven years my mother and I have started talking properly. 
Her past has brought us closer together.
Angela recently decided to sell her mother’s archival collection through 
London’s Sotheby’s; "My mother, who is now 83 needs to undergo an operation on 
her eyes and we simply need the money. I believe it will afford my mother the 
opportunity to lead a more comfortable life. I also believe that her story 
should be told. By making it public,
more people will learn about this 
terrible time in our history."
Box 1
The extraordinary story of love and survival is told through a collection of personal letters and official documents which was sold by Angela Schluter. These included;
More than 250 letters written by Edith to Pepi
23 pages of letters from Pepi 
to Edith
More than 40 photographs of Edith, Pepi and Werner and Angela, their 
daughter
Illicit photographs from Edith’s Labour camp
letters written 
under Edith’s assumed name
Edith’s German passport, stamped with a ‘J’
Letters from Werner smuggled out of Siberia in a spectacle case
|  | |
The Nazi Officer's Wife by Edith Hahn Beer with Susan Dworkin
William Morrow, $26
Review by L.D. Meagher
November 16, 1999
(CNN) -- Those of us who did not witness the Holocaust 
sometimes have trouble appreciating just how deeply it affected life in Europe 
during the 1930s and 40s. As Nazi Germany extended its tendrils across the 
continent, entire populations were uprooted, displaced and destroyed.
"The Nazi Officer's Wife" isn't about all those people. It's about one.
Edith Hahn was a 24-year-old law student in Vienna when the Nazis closed their 
grip on Austria. She was bright and attractive. She was involved in the great 
political debates of the day. She was in love. Her future was unfolding like a 
glittering carpet before her. Then it was gone. With the Nazis in power, Edith 
no longer had a future. She was stripped of it because she was a Jew.
Six years later, not only was Edith still alive, she was living the life of a 
middle-class German hausfrau, tending to her young daughter while her husband 
was serving as an officer in the German Army on the Russian front. She had given 
up her entire identity, had discarded all hope of seeing her family again, and 
had become what was called a "U-boat" -- she was a Jew submerged in Nazi 
Germany, masquerading as a loyal Aryan daughter of the Fatherland.
Edith survived when millions of other Jews were exterminated. What does that 
make her? In "The Nazi Officer's Wife," it becomes clear that she doesn't 
consider herself heroic. She does consider herself immensely fortunate, even 
blessed, to have lived through the horror of Hitler-era Germany.
Edith Hahn Beer tells her story of survival in an understated tone that makes 
her ordeal seem all the more harrowing. Today, we might have trouble 
understanding the position she was in. If anyone around her had discovered her 
true identity, she would have died instantly and excruciatingly. Never for a 
moment did she forget that. Not even at the moment her daughter was born. Edith 
worked as a Red Cross nurse and had heard women blurt out their most intimate 
secrets under anesthesia. When her time came, she refused drugs, opting for 
"natural" childbirth seven years before Dr. Lamaze introduced the concept to 
Western Europe.
Beer describes her younger self in Vienna as a rather starry-eyed dreamer who 
dared seek the university education usually reserved for young men. Her vision 
cleared quickly and dramatically once the Nazis took over her school. She 
reported for her final examination, which she needed to pass in order to 
practice law. A clerk informed her flatly she would not take the exam, she was 
no longer welcome in the school and she should get out. Five years of studies, 
up in smoke. "She turned her back on me," Beer writes. "I could feel her sense 
of triumph, her genuine satisfaction in destroying my life. It had a smell, I 
tell you -- like sweat, like lust."
It was the first of many hard lessons Edith Hahn Beer would learn as her world crumbled around her and a new, hostile one rose in its place. In the end, however, she expresses little bitterness over the hand fate dealt her. She didn't set out to dupe the Nazi war machine. It just worked out that way. She doesn't mask her scorn for the Germans and Austrians who stood by idly as the Holocaust unfolded. But she also doesn't overlook small acts of kindness that helped ease her own suffering.
"The Nazi Officer's Wife" could have been a flashy 
book filled with high drama and brimming over with grand emotion. That it isn't 
provides a reflection of the person telling the story. Edith Hahn Beer never 
wanted to be clever or brave, famous or notorious. She just wanted to stay 
alive.
L.D. Meagher is a senior writer at CNN Headline News. He has worked in 
broadcasting for 30 years.
Pode ler:
BBC World Service review: http://www.bbc.co.uk/worldservice/people/highlights/edith.shtml